A dated fireplace can significantly impact the overall ambiance of a room, often becoming an eyesore that detracts from the space’s comfort and appeal. In the case of the Tassone family, their 1980s ranch house in Twin Lakes, Wisconsin, featured a gas fireplace in the family room that was so unappealing that the couple and their three children avoided spending time in the space altogether.
However, with some creativity and budget-friendly solutions, you can transform your outdated fireplace into a stunning focal point. This guide will walk you through what it takes to revamp your fireplace on a budget, using the inspiring story of Erin and Kurt Tassone’s fireplace makeover as an example of what can be achieved for under $800.
Planning Your Fireplace Renovation
Before diving into your fireplace makeover, you’ll need to carefully plan your project to ensure the best results within your budget.
Assessing Your Current Fireplace
Start by thoroughly examining your existing fireplace. Take note of the following:
- The current materials and their condition
- Any structural issues that need addressing
- The size and shape of the fireplace
- The surrounding wall space and potential for built-ins or shelving
- The existing mantel (if any) and its style
Setting a Realistic Budget
Once you have a clear idea of what needs to be done, it’s time to set a budget. The Tassones completed their fireplace makeover for just $795, which proves that a significant transformation is possible without a hefty price tag. Here are some tips for keeping costs down:
- Prioritize the most impactful changes
- Look for sales and discounts on materials
- Consider DIY options for parts of the project
- Repurpose or upcycle existing items when possible
- Shop secondhand for certain elements, such as cabinets or decorative pieces
DIY Fireplace Makeover Techniques
With your plan and budget in place, it’s time to roll up your sleeves and get to work. Here are some DIY techniques that can help you achieve a beautiful fireplace makeover on a budget.
Removing Old Finishes and Materials
The first step in most fireplace makeovers is removing the outdated elements. In the Tassones’ case, they started by removing the faux stone and dark hearth tile. This process can be labor-intensive but is doable for DIYers. Be sure to take proper safety precautions, such as wearing protective gear and ensuring proper ventilation.
Updating the Surround with Stone Veneer
One of the most impactful changes you can make to a fireplace is updating the surround. The Tassones chose to install stacked-stone veneer, which provides a modern, textured look. Stone veneer is an excellent option for a DIY project as it’s lighter and easier to install than full stone. To build a stone veneer fireplace surround, you’ll need to prepare the surface, apply mortar, and carefully place each piece of veneer for a natural look.
Refreshing Fireplace Doors and Trim
If your fireplace has dated doors or trim, you don’t necessarily need to replace them. The Tassones gave their brass fireplace doors a new lease on life by spray-painting the trim black with heat-resistant paint. This simple and inexpensive update (costing only $5 in their case) is the best way to drastically change the look of your fireplace without breaking the bank.
Enhancing Your Fireplace Area
A fireplace makeover isn’t just about the fireplace itself — it’s also about creating a cohesive and functional space around it.
Adding Built-In Storage Solutions
Built-in storage can add both functionality and visual appeal to your fireplace area. The Tassones installed secondhand cabinets on both sides of their fireplace to house puzzles and games, with open shelves above for their TV, photos, and artwork.
Creating a Custom Mantel
A new mantel can significantly change the look of your fireplace. The Tassones enlisted the help of a family member to create a custom mantel shelf, replicating a pricey design they had seen for a fraction of the cost. If you’re handy with woodworking, creating a custom mantel can be an affordable way to add a high-end touch to your fireplace.
Incorporating Decorative Elements
The finishing touches can make all the difference in your fireplace makeover. Consider adding elements like:
- A large mirror or artwork above the mantel
- Decorative objects on the mantel or built-in shelves
- Plants or greenery to add life to the space
- Textured elements like baskets or woven items for warmth
Cost Breakdown of a $795 Fireplace Renovation
To give you a rough idea of how to allocate your budget, here’s a breakdown of the Tassones’ $795 fireplace makeover:
- New drywall, stone veneer, and stone slabs: $500
- Room paint (soft green): $30
- Heat-resistant spray paint for fireplace doors: $5
- Open shelves and crown molding: $200
- Custom mantel and flea market window frame: $60
Maximizing Fireplace Warmth and Efficiency
Regular maintenance ensures your fireplace operates safely and efficiently. Have your chimney inspected and cleaned annually and check for and repair any damage to the firebox. Be sure to keep the area around the fireplace clear of any flammable materials and install and maintain smoke detectors and carbon monoxide detectors for safety. Finally, regularly cleaning the glass and doors will also help keep your fireplace running efficiently.
Choosing the Right Firewood
If you have a wood-burning fireplace, selecting the right firewood is crucial for optimal performance:
- Use seasoned hardwoods like oak, maple, or hickory
- Avoid softwoods like pine, which can create more creosote buildup
- Store firewood properly to keep it dry
- Split logs to the appropriate size for your fireplace
Common Misconceptions About Fireplaces
There are several misconceptions about fireplaces that are worth addressing to help homeowners make informed decisions about their use and maintenance.
Do Fireplaces Really Keep Your House Warm?
While fireplaces can provide supplemental heat, they’re not always the most efficient heating source. Traditional open fireplaces can actually cause heat loss as warm air from the room is drawn up the chimney. However, modern fireplace inserts and sealed units can significantly improve heating efficiency, making them more effective at warming your home.
Do Fireplaces Cool Your House?
Contrary to some beliefs, fireplaces don’t actively cool your house. However, if not properly sealed, they can allow cool air to enter your home during the summer months. Using a chimney balloon or damper can help prevent this unwanted air exchange and maintain your home’s temperature more effectively.
Our Conclusion
A fireplace makeover can dramatically transform a room, creating a warm and inviting focal point that enhances your entire home. As demonstrated by the Tassones’ project, it’s possible to achieve a stunning renovation on a budget of less than $800 with some creativity and DIY effort.
