Gutter Guards America Review (2024)
Clicking “Get Your Estimate” submits your data to Home Service Quotes, which will process your data in accordance with the Home Service Quotes Privacy Policy.
Ad Disclaimer
We awarded Gutter Guards America 4.6 out of 5 stars for its impressive micro-mesh gutter guards and host of additional services. It’s a good choice for homeowners within its limited service area.
Gutter Guards America is a smaller but well-trusted brand operating on the East Coast and in the Midwest. Its micro-mesh guard features a raised, ridged design and impressive gutter protection. Gutter Guards America offers a wide selection of additional services, including gutter installation, roof replacement, and more. We recommend Gutter Guards America as one of the best gutter guard brands within its service area of Ohio, North Carolina, South Carolina, and Georgia.
We reviewed Gutter Guards America’s services, analyzed its warranty, and read every customer review we could find online. We also surveyed 1,000 homeowners who have had gutter guards professionally installed, including 279 Gutter Guards America customers, to learn more about guard performance and price. Read on to learn if Gutter Guards America is the best choice for your gutter protection needs.
What Do We Think of Gutter Guards America?
We like Gutter Guards America for its impressive gutter guard, positive customer reviews, and wide selection of service offerings. The downside to this brand is its limited operating area of four states.
Gutter Guards America uses a micro-mesh gutter guard system made from high-end materials with a unique, raised design. It has among the highest customer review scores we’ve seen on Trustpilot, with 4.5 out of 5 stars based on more than 600 reviews.
Gutter Guards America received the highest satisfaction score in our survey of 1,000 homeowners. Overall, 89% of respondents were satisfied with how their gutter guards performed, and 71% were very satisfied.
Pros and Cons
Pros
- Uses a raised micro-mesh screen made from stainless steel
- Offers gutter, downspout, and roof replacement services
- Has high customer service scores on Trustpilot
Cons
- Operates in only four states
- Doesn’t offer gutter guard color options
- Advertises misleading claim that its guards keep you off the ladder
What We Think Sets Gutter Guards America Apart
We are impressed by Gutter Guards America’s product quality, wide service selection, and customer review scores. Overall, Gutter Guards America is a solid gutter guard company.
Our firsthand testing of more than a dozen gutter guards revealed that the most effective gutter guard type is a micro-mesh screen, which is the design offered by Gutter Guards America. This type of system blocks the most debris and has good water passability, meaning it keeps out debris while letting water pass through your gutters.
Gutter Guards America’s material quality is also impressive. The mesh screen is made from stainless steel, the system’s body is aluminum, and the louvered supports are galvanized steel. These high-quality materials make this gutter protection system long-lasting, corrosion-resistant, and durable.
Gutter Guards America’s service offerings are more comprehensive than most gutter guard providers. Most gutter guard companies we’ve reviewed offer gutter guard, downspout, and gutter installation services. Some companies also provide gutter cleaning and repair services. Gutter Guards America offers all these services, plus roof repair and replacement. This offering makes Gutter Guards America a one-stop shop for homeowners looking for comprehensive roofing and gutter services.
What we like the most about Gutter Guards America is its review scores. On Trustpilot, it boasts 4.5 out of 5 stars with more than 600 responses. Of these reviews, 77% were 5 out of 5 stars. Our survey of 279 Gutter Guards America customers reinforces these findings. Our respondents indicated that its performance was impressive. It had the highest customer satisfaction score of every company we surveyed, with 89% of respondents being satisfied or very satisfied with Gutter Guards America.
Where We Think Gutter Guards America Could Improve
We think that Gutter Guards America falls short in two specific areas: guard design and operating area. While we’re impressed by its guard’s material quality and micro-mesh screen, its raised and wave-like design presents some problems.
Micro-mesh screens perform well because they create a flat, tight surface that encourages debris to slide right off. Gutter Guards America’s screen has ridges that create small gaps between the frame and the mesh surface. Despite the company’s “no clog guarantee,” we suspect these small gaps could cause an accumulation of debris, specifically shingle grit and pine needles. We read every available customer review for Gutter Guards America and noted that some customers did complain about shingle grit and pine needle buildup.
The other major issue is its limited operating area. Gutter Guards America has only six locations across four states: Georgia, Ohio, North Carolina, and South Carolina.
Gutter Guards America Cost
Like most gutter guard companies, Gutter Guards America doesn’t post cost information on its website. We surveyed 279 Gutter Guards America customers to see what they paid for their gutter guard system. According to our respondents, Gutter Guards America guards cost an average of $26.35 per linear foot. Based on this pricing, expect to pay $5,270 for a 200-linear-foot gutter guard system.
Compare the Best Gutter Guards
Gutter Guards America’s limited operating area means it isn’t an option for customers who live outside of Georgia, North Carolina, Ohio, and South Carolina. If you live outside of this service area, review the following table for an at-a-glance comparison of Gutter Guards America to national-level gutter guard installers that we also recommend:
| Company | Logo | Star Rating | BBB Rating | Price Range | Warranty | Link |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
 | A+ | $15 to $45 per linear foot | Lifetime transferable | Get Quote | ||
 | A+ | $11-$37 per linear foot | Lifetime transferable | Get Quote | ||
 | A+ | $7.50–$10/foot | Lifetime transferable | Read Our Review |
How Gutter Guards America Compares to DIY Alternatives
Based on our research and firsthand testing, we think Gutter Guards America is superior to almost all DIY gutter guards. We’ve tested most major DIY gutter guard brands, and Raptor by Gutterglove comes close to the performance of a professionally installed product. Raptor uses a stainless steel micro-mesh screen set in an aluminum frame. Gutter Guards America’s guard quality and superb customer service make it a solid choice for most homeowners.
You pay for the quality of a professional installation, and gutter guard installation costs between $4,000 and $7,000 on average. DIY gutter guards cost between $170 and $700 to install, so Raptor offers a quality option for homeowners on a budget.
How Does Gutter Guards America Work?
Gutter Guards America uses a stainless steel micro-mesh screen set into an aluminum frame with a galvanized steel support structure. The screen’s raised, wave-like design aids with debris filtration and water flow.
After testing every major type of gutter guard, we found that micro-mesh systems performed the best—this guard blocks the most debris, including shingle grit, pine needles, and deciduous tree leaves. Upon analyzing Gutter Guards America’s system, we believe it would perform well. Its micro-mesh screen should keep out the majority of debris while still allowing water to pass into your gutter system without overflowing.
Our only major concern is its screen’s wave-like design. The small openings it has could allow shingle grit, dirt, pine needles, and other small particles to build up and create a clog. We think this guard should work to prevent debris build-up, but it will still need to be cleaned at least once a year.
How Easy Is Gutter Guards America To Clean?
We believe that Gutter Guards America’s gutter covers are easy to clean. After testing every kind of gutter guard, our team found that micro-mesh guards were the easiest to clean. Waterflow pushes most debris off of micro-mesh guards. What remains is easy to remove with a light brushing or spraying with a hose.
Our only concern with Gutter Guards America’s guards is the small “pockets” created by the wave-like pattern of the screen. These may create recesses that trap shingle grit and pine needles. Otherwise, most debris should slide off the guards.
Gutter Guards America advertises its commitment to “keeping homeowners off the ladder.” While gutter guards can reduce the time you spend on a ladder, no gutter guard completely eliminates the need for regular gutter cleaning. We recommend cleaning your gutters at least once a year if you have guards installed.
What Does Gutter Guards America’s Warranty Cover?
Gutter Guard America offers two warranties: one for its gutter guards and another for its gutter system.
Its gutter guard’s lifetime transferable warranty promises that if you experience a problem with your system, Gutter Guards America will make it right. Gutter Guards America states, “Under this warranty, we guarantee that the quality and workmanship of our services will meet your highest standards. Should you encounter any issues within the warranty period, our dedicated team of professionals is just a call away, ready to address and resolve them promptly and efficiently.”
Its gutter warranty is similar, but it also covers the workmanship and installation of the system. We searched for more information on these warranties, including their limits, coverage, and eligibility, but Gutter Guards America’s website lacked any further information.
What Are Customers Saying About Gutter Guards America?
After researching Gutter Guards America and other gutter guard companies, we found that it has one of the industry’s highest average customer review scores: 4.5 out of 5 stars on Trustpilot.
Gutter Guards America has an A+ Better Business Bureau (BBB) rating and accreditation. It only has three BBB reviews, making its 2- out of 5-star rating unreliable as an average. However, its Trustpilot and Google Review scores provide more information. On Trustpilot, it has 4.5 out of 5 stars with more than 600 reviews, 88% of which are 4 or 5 out of 5 stars. On Google, it has 52 reviews with a score of 4.4 out of 5 stars. LeafFilter, our top recommended brand, has more than 125,000 reviews on Trustpilot, 82% of which are 4- to 5-star reviews.
Trustpilot reviewers praise Gutter Guards America’s professionalism and the effectiveness of its products. Other positive reviews mention the promptness of its installation crews. The negative reviews we found mentioned inconsistent installation quality and occasional clogging. The most consistent issue we saw was poor installations, including mismatched parts or failure to clean up the jobsite.
Read a sample of Gutter Guards America customer reviews below:
Positive Reviews
Negative Reviews
How Are Gutter Guards America’s Gutter Guards Installed?
To purchase Gutter Guards America’s gutter guard installation services, contact Gutter Guards America via its website, phone number, or online chat system. Once you contact a customer service representative, they’ll schedule an appointment for a free consultation and estimate. On that date, a sales rep will come to your home, inspect your gutter system, and explain how the Gutter Guards America system works. They’ll also explain your installation cost and provide a free, no-obligation quote.
If you agree with the price, the sales representative will schedule an installation date. On that day, a service crew will arrive at your home. They’ll begin the guard installation process alongside any additional home services you requested, such as gutter repair or downspout installation. If you chose gutter guard installation, your installers will follow this process:
- Clean your existing gutter system
- Repair or replace any damaged sections
- Install the gutter guard system
- Remove any debris from the work area
- Show you the final product, typically with photos of the completed system
- Answer any questions you may have and depart
FAQ About Gutter Guards America
Does Gutter Guards America install gutters?
Yes, Gutter Guards America installs gutters in addition to professional gutter guard installation services. It offers standard and seamless aluminum gutter installations.
Who makes the best gutter guards?
LeafFilter makes the best gutter guards for most homes and climates. This micro-mesh guard performed the best during our product testing, keeping out debris as small as shingle grit while promoting water flow. It was also easy to clean.
Is there a downside to gutter guards?
Yes, the main downside to gutter guards is their high upfront cost. They also require yearly maintenance and cleaning, despite some claims that you’ll never need to clean your gutters after having gutter guards installed.
Does Gutter Guards America offer free estimates?
Yes, Gutter Guards America offers free, no-obligation estimates. You’ll have to schedule a free, at-home inspection to receive a pricing estimate tailored to your home and gutter system.
Are gutter guards worth it?
Yes, gutter guards are worth it if you want to make future gutter cleaning and maintenance quicker and easier. This home improvement project may not be worth it if you live in a climate that receives little rainfall or you don’t have trees surrounding your home.
Our Rating Methodology
Our team backs up our gutter guard recommendations with a detailed rating methodology to objectively score each gutter guard product and provider. We conduct research by reviewing product specifications and provider website information, speaking with customer representatives, and analyzing customer reviews. We reinforce this research with thorough firsthand product testing, assessing each gutter guard’s durability, quality, filtration, and cleanability. To date, we’ve tested more than a dozen professionally installed and DIY gutter guard products. We then score each provider against our review standards for gutter guard design, customer support, the quote process, services, and reviews to arrive at a final score on a 5-point rating scale.
To share feedback or ask a question about this article, send a note to our team at reviews@thisoldhousereviews.com.
