We recommend All American Gutter Protection if you want a reliable micro-mesh gutter guard and live in one of the 15 states it serves. While All American is a relatively small company with a more limited service area than many of the gutter industry’s bigger brands, we found that it has earned a place among the best gutter guard companies in the business. Its products perform well, and it offers deals and discounts that distinguish it from other professional gutter guard installers. 

Our All American Gutter Protection review considers everything you need to know about the brand, including its pros, cons, warranty, and customer sentiment.

---

Pros and Cons

Here are the upsides and downsides of All American Gutter Protection gutter guards:

Pros

• Features a micro-mesh filter that blocks pine needles well
• Has a reinforced aluminum sub-structure that shields the system from impacts
• Offers a range of discounts for seniors and military

Cons

• Doesn’t offer additional gutter services
• Scores lower than average in customer reviews
• Operates in only 15 states

---

Fast Facts

Our rating: 3.9/5

Average cost: $5,868 per 200 linear feet

Warranty: Lifetime transferable

Type: Micro-mesh stainless steel

Financing: Through the Wells Fargo home projects credit card

State availability: 15

---

Our Take on All American Gutter Protection

The design and materials of All American’s gutter guard system set it apart from other gutter installers. It uses stainless steel for its micro-mesh design and aluminum for its frame. 

This system withstands weathering and prevents debris as small as pine needles from entering your gutters while letting water flow through. It’s set within a lightweight and corrosion-resistant aluminum frame, making it one of the top gutter guards for pine needles.

All American installs aluminum seamless gutters in more than 30 colors. Seamless gutters are superior to standard sectional systems because they don’t use connectors (also called joiners), making them less prone to leaks and giving them a longer shelf life.

---

All American Gutter Protection Overview

All American offers an effective product made from high-quality materials. All American guards feature a stainless steel micro-mesh screen and aluminum body, materials that can withstand harsh weather and last up to 20 years in most conditions.

We tested more than a dozen of the highest-rated DIY gutter guards on the market and found that micro-mesh filters performed the best out of any guard type. Micro-mesh keeps gutters clog-free while allowing water to filter through the guard, even in heavy rain. Its micro-mesh design is a major point in All American Gutter Protection’s favor.

Based on its locations page, All American Gutter Protection is available in the following states: Colorado, Florida, Georgia, Illinois, Indiana, Kentucky, Michigan, New Jersey, North Carolina, Ohio, Pennsylvania, South Carolina, Tennessee, Wisconsin, and Southern Wyoming.

Cost

We surveyed 200 All American Gutter Protection customers. Our research shows that All American gutter guards cost an average of $5,868 for 200 linear feet, or $29.34 per linear foot. Based on our survey, the typical cost range for an All American Gutter Protection installation is between $3,900 and $5,900.

The national average cost for a professional gutter guard installation is between $1,800 and $3,500, but high-quality micro-mesh installations can cost up to $8,000. Factors such as your home’s size, total linear feet of guttering, roof pitch, and local labor rates all affect the cost of your gutter guard installation. 

All American offers generous discounts, which often change with the seasons. For example, as of December 2024, the company offered 30% off if you used a coupon found on its website. Past discounts have included 20% for whole-home installation.

We read its discount page and noted the following discounts are currently available:

• Senior discount: 10% off for anyone over the age of 60
• Military discount: 10% off for active duty, reserve, or retired service members

Financing

While All American Gutter Protection doesn’t advertise in-house financing for customers, it encourages those who seek financing to do so through the Wells Fargo Home Projects credit card. 

Warranty

We read All American’s warranty page and noted its lifetime performance guarantee. This guarantees that “our gutter protection products will work as described in your contract for the life of your home.” The warranty page also notes, “If our gutters and gutter guards fail to meet your expectations for any reason, give us a call and we’ll do all we can to make it right.” 

Fine Print

The warranty’s conditions are somewhat vague, so we called All American and spoke to a representative. They informed us that the warranty lasts the lifetime of the home and completely covers the guards’ performance. If the guards leak, break, or fail to prevent materials from entering the gutters, All American will send a representative to handle it. We were told that information regarding limitations and coverages was only available through an inspector and sales representative.

Materials

The well-engineered materials used by All American Gutter Protection are an important distinguishing quality. We found that stainless steel micro-mesh gutter guards performed best for debris filtration and water flow during our testing, and that’s only one aspect of the All American system.

All American’s gutter covers feature its stainless steel micro-mesh screen set within an aluminum frame. It has a supporting aluminum sub-structure and reinforcing hidden hangers. This creates a durable, corrosion-resistant shield that prevents debris buildup and clogs while allowing water passage.

Cleaning and maintaining your gutters is easier with micro-mesh gutter guards because you don’t have to dig through the trough of your gutters to clear gunk. As debris falls on your roof and gutter system, it will collect atop the guard or be pushed to the ground by water. The flat, smooth surface of the guard makes removing debris easy with a quick rinse with a hose. 

Additional Services

All American Gutter Protection doesn’t offer a wide range of additional services. Most professional gutter guard installers include basic gutter maintenance options for customers. Gutter cleaning and repair are common industry standards for these companies. All American only offers gutter guard, seamless gutter, and downspout installations as well as fascia replacements.

---

Quote and Installation Process

To work with All American Gutter Protection, contact them through an online form on its website or by phone. A customer service representative will schedule an appointment for an on-site inspection and free quote.

On that day, a salesperson will arrive at your home and inspect your existing gutter and roof system. They’ll look for anything that can affect the price of your new gutter guard installation, such as your roof pitch and total linear feet of guttering. After they inspect your system, they’ll give you a sales pitch on All American’s products and services, present your quote, and negotiate on price. They’ll schedule an installation date if you agree to the quote.

An installation crew will arrive at your home on that date. They’ll clean, make any necessary repairs, and install your new gutter guards. If you purchased seamless gutters with your guards, they’ll also remove your old system, roll and cut your new gutters to custom-fit your home, and install them. They’ll clean up the job site, dispose of remaining debris, and answer any questions you may have before departing.

---

All American Gutter Protection Customer Reviews: Trustpilot, BBB, Yelp, and More

All American Gutter Protection has among the smallest pool of reviews out of every company we’ve reviewed. On Trustpilot, All American has a five-star single review. Its BBB page has 31 reviews, with an average score of 3.4 out of 5 stars. Unfortunately, we don’t think there’s a large enough sample size of reviews to get an accurate glimpse into All American’s performance. However, here are sample reviews that highlight positive and negative themes we noted:

As a smaller company, it’s unsurprising that All American has fewer online reviews. To learn more about consumer sentiment, we surveyed 200 All American customers. According to our results, 71% of respondents were satisfied with the performance of their All American systems. The average percentage of satisfied customers out of every company we surveyed was 72.6%, meaning that All American falls in line with the industry average for customer satisfaction. Of our respondents, 102 noted previous issues with pine needles. Only six of those said they were unsatisfied with the performance of the guard.

---

How All American Gutter Protection Compares to Other Top Gutter Guard Companies

Although All American’s rating of 3.9 out of 5 stars is among the lowest of the major gutter guard companies we reviewed, its ability to effectively block pine needle buildup, its combination of stainless steel micro-mesh screens and aluminum base, and its generous deals and discounts help it earn a place among our recommended gutter guard installers.

Advertisement

This site receives compensation from some of the companies featured in this listing, which may impact where and how products appear. When you click “Get Quote,” you will be connected with partners who may contact you with information related to your inquiry. This listing doesn’t feature all companies, products, or offers that may be available.

Brand	Logo	Our Rating	Average Cost (Per 200 Linear Feet)	Guard Type	Warranty	Link
LeafFilterGet Quote		4.7/5	$5,528	Stainless steel micro-mesh	Lifetime transferable	Get Quote
LeafguardGet Quote		4.2/5	$7,900	Aluminum reverse-curve	Lifetime transferable	Get Quote
Gutter Guards AmericaRead Our Review		4.6/5	$5,270	Stainless steel micro-mesh	Lifetime transferable	Read Our Review
All American Gutter ProtectionRead Our Review		3.9/5	$5,868	Stainless steel micro-mesh	Lifetime transferable	Read Our Review
HomeCraft Gutter ProtectionRead Our Review		4.2/5	$6,338	Stainless steel micro-mesh	Lifetime transferable	Read Our Review

---

FAQ About All American Gutter Protection Gutter Guards

Who owns All American Gutter Protection?

Ohio home improvement entrepreneur Dennis Elliott owns and founded All American Gutter Protection with fellow entrepreneur and company President Aaron Brosch. The company was founded in 2015 with one location in Northeast Ohio and expanded to locations in 15 states in the past decade.

Does All American install gutters?

Yes, All American installs gutters. It offers seamless aluminum gutter installations.

Can you install All American on existing gutters?

Yes, you can install All American on existing gutters. Unlike some gutter guards that are one-piece systems and must be installed as a new gutter and gutter guard, All American guards can be installed over old gutters.

What services does All American Gutter Protection offer?

All American Gutter Protection offers gutter, downspout, and gutter guard installation services as well as fascia replacement. It doesn’t offer gutter cleaning and repair services.

What is the downside of All American?

All American’s biggest downside is its lack of additional roof and gutter services and reports of inconsistent installation quality in customer reviews.

---

How We Evaluated Gutter Guard Brands

To provide fair and accurate comparisons of the top gutter guard installers, we developed a comprehensive review methodology to measure and score brands. Our review standards were developed based on interviews with industry experts, consumer reviews and surveys, and the factors that guide homeowners as they make buying decisions, including material and design, warranty coverage, value, services offered, and effectiveness.

Our Rating System

Our rating system was derived from thorough research and hands-on experience. We analyzed gutter guard installers’ websites, tracked third-party ratings, and gauged consumer sentiment to complete our understanding of each gutter guard company. We reinforced this research with firsthand data by purchasing, installing, and testing gutter guard systems. 

Here are a few details about our research methodology:

• First-party research: We comprehensively researched each provider’s website to learn about its products, services, warranty, payment options, and more. We also collected proprietary data by surveying homeowners who have had gutter guards installed. 
• Third-party ratings: We read and analyzed consumer reviews and ratings on reputable third-party sites such as the BBB, Trustpilot, Google Reviews, and Yelp. This reveals potential patterns of customer complaints and favorable outcomes.
• Hands-on testing: For DIY products, we order and test for filtration effectiveness, durability, and more. For installation companies, we request a showroom floor and perform a series of tests to determine performance and quality.

To share feedback or ask a question about this article, send a note to our team at reviews@thisoldhousereviews.com.