9 Best Dog Toys

Dog toys keep your furry friend entertained while increasing mental stimulation and staving off boredom. Read on to learn more about the best dog toys for your pet.

Written by This Old House Reviews Team Updated 08/03/2022

Just like people, dogs like to have fun, too. From bones to plushies, dog toys help stimulate your canine’s mind, eliminate boredom, and even provide a fun way to exercise.

However, with so many options available, shopping your way through hundreds of dog toys can be overwhelming. To help you select the right toy for your furry friend, we researched a variety of toys, looking into their cost, durability, and purpose. Take a look at some of our top selections below.

Top 9 Dog Toys

KONG Classic Dog Toy: Best Overall
ZippyPaws Burrow Squeaky Hide and Seek Plush Dog Toy, Hedgehog Den, Puzzle Set: Best Plush Toy
Benebone Bacon Flavor Wishbone Tough Dog Chew Toy: Best Chew Toy
KONG Jumbler Ball Dog Toy: Best Toy for Fetch
Frisco Hide and Seek Plush Chewy Box Puzzle Dog Toy: Best Interactive Toy
Bones & Chews Made in USA Cotton Rope with Bones Dog Toy: Best Rope and Tug Toy
Goody Box Birthday Dog Toys, Treats, & Bandana: Best Variety Box
Mammoth Cotton Blend 3 Knot Dog Rope Toy: Best Cheap Dog Toy
Starmark Fantastic DuraFoam Ball Tough Dog Toy: Best Ball for Dogs

KONG Classic Dog Toy: Best Overall

The classics are hard to beat, a sentiment that holds true for dog toys. The versatile KONG Classic Dog Toy is great for dog owners looking for multiple ways to scratch their dog’s playful itch.

Its all-natural exterior is made with bouncy durable rubber that’s great for chewing and playing, while its interior can be filled with peanut butter or other dog treats to satisfy your doggy’s cravings. The affordable option from KONG toys may help curb your furry friend’s boredom, separation anxiety, and incessant desire to chew.

Color Choices

Good For:

Extra-small dogs
Small dogs
Medium dogs
Large dogs
Extra-large dogs

Most Helpful Positive Review

LindaB on Chewy says:

“We adopted a new rescue. As soon as I opened the Chewy box and she saw the Kong – her tail started wagging. She has had one of these before, I’m sure. She’s been chewing it and tossing it in the air. She took it on her walk and even took it to bed. When I put something in it, she’ll be over the moon!”

Most Helpful Critical Review

JRTmom on Chewy says:

“My Jack Russell Terrier was able to chew through this within 15 minutes! We will try the extreme chewers moving forward but I am surprised that is needed for a dog his size and strength.”

ZippyPaws Burrow Squeaky Hide and Seek Plush Dog Toy, Hedgehog Den, Puzzle Set: Best Plush Toy

If your canine loves squeaky plush dog toys, this combination set from ZippyPaws might be a worthwhile purchase. Coming with three squeaky hedgehogs that fit inside of an included den, this toy can keep your dog stimulated for hours.

Additionally, if your dog loves to slobber, you can easily clean the toy’s machine-washable exterior. While these plushies are great for small and medium-sized dogs, they aren’t indestructible and may not be suitable for large dog breeds or tough chewers.

Good For:

Extra-small dogs
Small dogs
Medium dogs

Most Helpful Positive Review

Buglet on Chewy says:

“My Cavalier King Charles Spaniel has loved all the interactive toys that I have bought from Chewy, and this adorable hedgehog den is no exception. He goes “nuts” when the hedgehogs are “hiding” in their den, and won’t stop until he has gotten all 3 of them laying on his pallet. It is hilarious to watch his tactics to remove them from their den. I highly recommend this toy.”

Most Helpful Critical Review

Ludwig on Chewy says:

“My pup really enjoyed it but within our first playtime, I noticed the seam coming apart. Only one of the toys remains intact which doesn’t make the toy as fun.”

Benebone Bacon Flavor Wishbone Tough Dog Chew Toy: Best Chew Toy

If your dog is a chewer, it’s best to keep them entertained. With the wishbone chew toy from Benebone, you can do just that. Made in the USA with durable nylon fused with real bacon flavor, this chew toy helps curb your dog’s destructive instincts. While this toy can help your canine relax, its non-edible design isn’t suitable for extreme chewers.

Good For:

Medium dogs
Large dogs

Most Helpful Positive Review

Luna on Chewy says:

“I have an Australian cattle dog mix that’s under 1 year old and she constantly needs something to do. This thing has been so helpful! She has chewed on it every single day for 30 minutes to 1 hour. I had no idea she would enjoy it so much. I’ve had it for over a month but the nubs are almost completely chewed down so I may need a new one soon! Great value.”

Most Helpful Critical Review

Aleffew on Chewy says:

“I have a lab/heeler mix, and this lasted about 3 days. She absolutely loved it, but I was afraid she was going to chip a tooth with how hard she was chewing on it. Their website has a good guide on when to throw away, but this isn’t a vet recommended chew toy because of how hard it is.”

KONG Jumbler Ball Dog Toy: Best Toy for Fetch

Nearly every dog has an affinity for a game of fetch in the backyard, from frisbees to balls. However, when you use tennis balls or other soft toys, playtime can be cut short by aggressive chewers. The KONG Jumbler Ball Dog Toy helps fetch last a bit longer with its two-in-one design.

Its interior squeaky tennis ball grabs your pup’s attention while its durable exterior and included handle makes pickup a bit easier. To cater to fetch lovers of all sizes, this toy is available in both medium/large and large/extra-large sizes.

Good For:

Medium dogs
Large dogs
Extra-large dogs

Most Helpful Positive Review

SeaAntz on Chewy says:

“This is the second time I have purchased this ball, it’s amazing! The first one lasted over a year and was replaced due to general wear from the weather. My dog cannot get enough of it! Every time she goes outside she’s ready to chase and squeak this ball. She’s a very tough chewer and destroys toys within 1-2 weeks, but she’s never been able to chew through this toy and it always keeps her entertained. I’m amazed, great quality!”

Most Helpful Critical Review

Kipper on Chewy says:

“My dog loves these . However, [the] squeaker usually stops working within a half hour. These are hard plastic so it usually takes a bit longer to chew holes in it. We play with it until holes are too big and she starts getting pieces off of it. I bet we have purchased 25 of these in the year and half since we rescued this dog. Last longer than soft rubber toys.”

Frisco Hide and Seek Plush Chewy Box Puzzle Dog Toy: Best Interactive Toy

Dog’s enjoy surprises, too. With this plush puzzle toy from Chewy, your dog can sift through its contents to find a rope toy, squeaker ball, and squeaker bone. To keep playtime going, you can stuff the toy’s back in the plush box after your dog digs them up.

Not only does this interactive dog toy grab your furry friend’s attention, it keeps their working mind stimulated to prevent boredom and the destructive habits that come along with it. It’s an ideal choice for dogs who prefer interactive squeaky toys.

Good For:

Small dogs
Medium dogs
Large dogs

Most Helpful Positive Review

9dogs on Chewy says:

“I have a Boston terrier, and as you guys know they are very intelligent dogs so she loves this toy. It’s like a puzzle to her and it can keep her happy for hours. I will absolutely buy this for her again.”

Most Helpful Critical Review

Emilia on Chewy says:

“My ultra playful dalmatian really loved the puzzle part as well as playing with all [the] toys on their own. But it only lasted about 2 days before he broke open the stuffed ball and a week before the bone and box were gone too. Rope is still going strong though …”

Bones & Chews Made in USA Cotton Rope with Bones Dog Toy: Best Rope and Tug Toy

When you have a tough chewer on your hands, the Bones & Chews cotton rope can help prevent their instincts from turning into destructive habits. Made with a cotton blend rope containing two slow-roasted bones, this toy could keep your pup’s attention for hours.

The affordable chew toy also comes in an array of vibrant colors shipped at random for a nice at-home surprise. Additionally, Bones and Chews is free from fillers and artificial flavors, colors, and preservatives, making it a favorite toy for conscientious pet parents.

Good For:

Small dogs
Medium dogs
Large dogs
Extra-large dogs

Most Helpful Positive Review

JFHDogs on Chewy says:

“My dogs are big and rough on toys and big chewers. They both love this toy and I wish I had bought more than one. Going to order more right now. It has held up fairly well.”

Most Helpful Critical Review

Cindye1010 on Chewy says:

“The string part was chewed up in less than a week. The bones are sturdy though and big enough that our Airedale can’t swallow them.”

Goody Box Birthday Dog Toys, Treats, & Bandana: Best Variety Box

If your dog’s birthday is around the corner, or you’re just looking to restock their toy and treat supply, the Goody Box from Chewy is a great option, containing two treats, two toys, and a decorative bandana. It could be ideal for multipet owners looking for gifts for the whole family.

To ensure you’re receiving quality products, Chewy handpicks the box’s contents using recommendations from fellow pet parents. Additionally, this variety box is free from subscriptions or commitments, so you can order a box whenever you want.

Good For:

Medium dogs
Large dogs

Most Helpful Positive Review

Qeia on Chewy says:

“Mocha received this birthday box for her 1st birthday. She loved EVERYTHING she received in the box! Her absolute favorite is the piñata. This is the only plush toy she has managed not to shred to bits within 2-3 days! The birthday candy plush toy is pretty sturdy too. I need more soft toys made with whatever the piñata and candy was made of!”

Most Helpful Critical Review

Sandy on Chewy says:

“Although this birthday box is filled with cute things, the rubber bone and stuffed animal are too big for a 5 pound dog. There was no option for an x-small dog but wanted to have a little something cute for my Amina’s 4th year of life. Next time I will buy items separately.”

Mammoth Cotton Blend 3 Knot Dog Rope Toy: Best Cheap Dog Toy

No matter the size of your dog, this affordable, three-knot rope toy from Mammoth can keep your furry friend or teething puppy satisfied and entertained.

The toy is built with rope fibers to keep your dog’s teeth clean from tartar and get bad breath under control. Additionally, its lightweight build makes it great for tug-of-war, fetch, or a variety of other games.

Good For:

Extra-small dogs
Small dogs
Medium dogs
Large dogs
Extra-large dogs

Most Helpful Positive Review

Punkinsmom on Chewy says:

“My little guy loves to chew on this rope. He is a rescue dog that never got toys, much less the joy of playing with them. I have tried all kinds of toys. This is the best. I highly recommend it. He is a small dog and I got a small one for him and a medium for our bigger dog. He loves the medium one. This rope is medium.”

Most Helpful Critical Review

Kevin on Chewy says:

“This is great for tug of war but not to just let your dog chew on. My little beagle mix chewed on it for a couple days and while I’m sure it was good for his teeth after a day or so he was getting little pieces off of it and swallowing them.”

Starmark Fantastic DuraFoam Ball Tough Dog Toy: Best Ball for Dogs

If you’re looking for a durable and affordable ball for your pooch, this Starmark ball toy is highly reviewed as one of the toughest options on the market.

Available in both medium and large sizes, the ball is ideal for indoor or outdoor fetch and has a long-lasting exterior made of patented foam that’s soft and safe on your dog’s gums. As an added bonus, the ball floats, making it an ideal fetch toy for playing on land or in the water.

Good For:

Small dogs
Medium dogs
Large dogs

Most Helpful Positive Review

MamaBear on Chewy says:

“I got this to take to the beach and springs for my Rottie – he loves it and I love that it floats so well. He’s not allowed to keep the ball and play with it, only fetch as it would not withstand a ton of chewing – but it’s great for a game of water fetch!”

Most Helpful Critical Review

JennM on Chewy says:

“I am always looking for tough toys for my pup. This one is durable, but leaves teeth marks. I would never leave him alone with this, because in a matter of minutes he will destroy it. I would NOT recommend this for a dog that needs “tough” toys.”

Buying Guide

When looking for a new dog toy, it’s important to understand your canine’s playstyle as well as factors such as the toy’s structure and designed use, and more.

Here are a few factors to consider before making a purchase:

Type

There are a variety of toys out there for your pup, each with their own unique set of benefits. The most common types of dog toys include rope toys, balls, and plushies.

Dog ropes: Dog ropes are great for the chewer in your life, as their thick material can keep your pup entertained for hours. However, these toys can be bulky and are typically preferred by larger breeds.
Balls: Balls are ideal for an active pup who loves to retrieve. Many dog balls today are made with durable natural rubber or neoprene, which should last your fetch-loving dog a few months.
Plushies: Plushies serve as excellent comfort toys for your pet, helping to reduce anxiety while staving off boredom. However, these toys are typically made with soft materials that are easily destroyed by heavy chewers, making them a better fit for snuggles than chewing.

Durability

Durability is another important factor when looking into dog toys, as you don’t want your investment to be chewed up after a few days. Toys made with rope and polyester typically don’t last as long as the non-toxic plastic seen in balls and other bones.

While most dog toys are safe, The Humane Society of the United States recommends dog-proofing any toys that have loose strings, eyes, and ribbons that can be easily ingested.

Size

Most dog toys come in multiple sizes to suit your dog’s needs, and it’s important to select the right one to encourage proper playing.

For example, if you have an extra-small or small dog, you’ll want a smaller-sized rope or ball that isn’t too heavy and can fit in their mouth. Conversely, if you have a larger breed that’s tough on toys, you may want to consider up-sizing your pup’s balls, ropes, and other toys.

Ease of use

Not all toys have a straightforward purpose like a ball for fetch or a rope for tug-of-war. Some models, such as activity boards or dog puzzle games, keep your dog entertained and intellectually stimulated by making them work for some sort of reward. Not only do these types of toys keep your dog’s attention, they also encourage your canine’s problem-solving skills.

Conclusion

Similar to other decisions you have to make as a pet owner, such as choosing the best leash for your dog or whether or not to get pet insurance, there’s no clear answer on the best toy for every dog. Each pup is unique, and it’s important to consider your dog’s temperament and play style before purchasing a toy.

Regardless of your dog’s toy preference, one of the Chewy products listed in this article can help your canine get the most out of playtime, whether they enjoy fetch, tug-of-war, or a good chew. If you’re interested in additional enrichment items for your dog, check out the online retailer’s list of thousands of toys available for quick shipping.

Other Pet Resources

Our Rating Methodology

In order to help pet parents find the best pet products, The This Old House Reviews Team has thoroughly researched and evaluated hundreds of pet products, weighing the factors below into our evaluation process:

Customer ratings: We selected products with a high volume of customer ratings across sites like Chewy and Google and a high average rating from verified customers.
Reviews: We analyzed at least 100 customer reviews for each pet product, factoring pet owners’ positive feedback and common complaints into our rankings.
Brand reputation: We also weighed each brand’s reputation in the pet industry, based on customer reviews and external research.
Features: We compared each product against competitors, comparing its basic and unique features, variety of options, and other factors specific to the type of product being reviewed.

After putting products through our rigorous review process, we follow up with experts and brand representatives when necessary, compile our research, and present you with a user-friendly, informative article featuring our top recommendations.

We regularly update our data points across the categories above to account for any changes to customer experience, product availability, and quality to help you make the most informed purchase possible for your pet.

To share feedback or ask a question about this article, send a note to our Reviews team at reviews@thisoldhousereviews.com.