As the 22nd season of Ask This Old House came to a close, the team took a moment to reflect on viewer feedback and address some of the comments received throughout the year. Host Kevin O’Connor sat down with the crew to discuss various projects, techniques, and even a few lighthearted observations. The team dug into the digital mailbag to share insights and defend their choices on recent projects.
Viewer Feedback On Utility Cover Project in Tulsa, Oklahoma
Nathan Gilbert’s utility cover project in Tulsa, Oklahoma, sparked some concern from viewers about its stability in windy conditions. One viewer on YouTube expressed worry that the three-sided structure might act as a windsail during storms or tornadoes.
Gilbert addressed these concerns by explaining:
- Safety considerations around gas meters prevent driving stakes into the ground
- The design prioritizes easy removal and replacement if needed
- Surprisingly, the structure withstood a tornado that damaged the homeowner’s carport
While the viewer’s concern is understandable, Gilbert’s design took into account both safety and practicality for the specific location and purpose of the utility cover.
In addition to addressing the immediate concerns, Gilbert highlighted the importance of considering local weather patterns and potential hazards when designing outdoor structures.
Feedback on the Rain Garden Project in Portland, Oregon
Landscape contractor Jenn Nawada’s rain garden project in Portland, Oregon, received criticism for not explicitly mentioning the importance of calling 811 before digging. This oversight raised concerns about safety practices.
Nawada clarified:
- The team always calls 811 at least 72 hours before any digging project
- Time constraints sometimes prevent showing every safety step in a single episode
- Safety remains the top priority for all Ask This Old House projects
While the omission in the final cut was unfortunate, viewers can rest assured that proper safety protocols are always followed behind the scenes.
In response to the feedback, Nawada also emphasized the educational aspect of the show. Each episode aims to inspire viewers to undertake their own projects while adhering to essential safety guidelines. By showcasing a variety of projects, the team reinforces the importance of thorough planning and precautionary measures, ensuring that viewers are well-informed about best practices. The rain garden project, while not exhaustive in its coverage of every detail, is a valuable resource for homeowners looking to make their yards sustainable.
Hot Water Heater Troubleshooting Criticism from Viewers
Plumbing and heating expert Richard Trethewey faced criticism for showcasing what some viewers perceived as overly complex or expensive heating and cooling systems. One commenter suggested the show should focus on simpler solutions.
Trethewey defended the show’s approach:
- Demonstrating cutting-edge technology educates viewers on the latest technologies
- The team strives to showcase the best and most current solutions available
- Variety in project complexity caters to different skill levels and interests among viewers
By featuring a range of technologies, from simple to advanced, Ask This Old House aims to provide comprehensive coverage of home improvement options.
Viewer Opinions on Low-Level CO Segment
Home technology expert Ross Trethewey addressed a comment about carbon monoxide (CO) levels discussed in a recent segment. The viewer pointed out that some CO is naturally present in the atmosphere and that low levels are not immediately life-threatening.
Trethewey recognized the need for nuance:
- The difference between carbon monoxide (CO) and carbon dioxide (CO2) is important to understand
- While zero CO is ideal, the segment could have been more precise by stating “low CO levels near 0.1 to 1 part per million (ppm)” instead of “zero CO” levels
Trethewey also stressed the significance of regular maintenance and monitoring of household systems that can produce CO. By using modern detection equipment and staying informed about the latest safety standards, homeowners can better protect themselves and their families from potential risks.
TOH Responds to Criticisms on Whitewashing an Antique Bench
Paint expert Mauro Henrique’s and Kevin O’Connor’s project whitewashing an antique bench received mixed feedback. One commenter found the result unappealing but appreciated the fun the hosts had during the process.
Henrique reflected on the project:
- Personal taste in design can vary widely among viewers
- The enjoyment and learning process are valuable aspects of DIY projects
- Showing techniques allows viewers to adapt them to their own style preferences
This project underscores that home improvement is not just about the end result but also about the journey and personal expression.
Henrique also highlighted the importance of experimentation in DIY projects. By trying out different techniques and materials, homeowners can discover new ways to personalize their spaces. The show’s goal is to inspire creativity and confidence, encouraging viewers to take on projects that reflect their individual tastes and preferences. While not every project will appeal to everyone, the skills and knowledge gained through the process are what matter most.
Feedback on Patio String Light Segment
Electrician Heath Eastman’s segment on installing patio string lights drew criticism from a viewer who felt the project was too simplistic. The comment sarcastically suggested that plugging in lights hardly warranted a full segment.
Eastman defended the value of the segment:
- Projects of varying complexity cater to different skill levels among viewers
- Simple projects can serve as building blocks for more advanced techniques
- Previous episodes have covered more complex electrical work, including receptacle installation
By including a range of project difficulties, Ask This Old House aims to be accessible to both beginners and experienced DIYers.
Levels 101 Segment Viewer Praise
General contractor Tom Silva received high praise for his Levels 101 segment, with one viewer declaring him the “GOAT” (Greatest of All Time). This positive feedback highlights the enduring appeal of Silva’s expertise and teaching style.
Silva’s segments continue to be a cornerstone of Ask This Old House, blending technical knowledge with approachable instruction.
Silva also shared his perspective on the evolution of home improvement techniques over the years. By staying abreast of new developments and integrating them into his teachings, he ensures that viewers benefit from both time-tested methods and new technology. This approach not only keeps the content fresh and relevant but also reinforces the show’s commitment to delivering high-quality, actionable information.
Viewer Appreciation and Show Impact
The Ask This Old House team received a heartfelt message from a long-time viewer. Praise for the show included the following:
- Blend of basic and complex information
- Wholesome approach to home improvement
- Focus on people helping people
- Focus on pride in craftsmanship
- Willingness of experts to both teach and learn
This feedback underscores the show’s lasting impact on viewers and its role in fostering a community of informed and capable homeowners.
The viewer’s appreciation serves as a testament to the show’s success in creating meaningful connections with its audience. This strong bond not only enhances the viewing experience but also motivates the crew to continue striving for excellence in every episode.
Our Conclusion
As Ask This Old House wrapped up its 22nd season, the crew’s engagement with viewer feedback showed their commitment to education, safety, and continuous improvement. From addressing concerns about project designs to explaining the rationale behind featuring various technologies, the team’s responses highlight the thoughtful approach behind each segment. The entire crew of Ask This Old House appreciates every viewer and encourages you to send in your feedback.
